Skip to main content

Which phone is best: Samsung Galaxy S4 vs. iPhone 5



How do you choose between the iPhone 5 and Galaxy S4? On the one hand, the iPhone 5 is an entirely known entity that just works. You might not be getting the most exciting or feature-rich smartphone, but at least you know exactly what you’re getting. Samsung’s Galaxy S4, on the other hand, is world’s apart from the iPhone 5: It’s huge, and massively powerful, and it has a ton of features that might be awesome or gimmicky, depending on your point of view.

The best bet, if you need help choosing between the iPhone 5 and Galaxy S4, is for us to start at the beginning: the hardware. We’ll then work our way up through the software, first- and third-party support, and other features that might break the tie.

Hardware and battery life
For the hardware analysis, we’ll be looking at the US version of the Galaxy S4, which has a quad-core Snapdragon 600 SoC with integrated LTE support. The Exynos Octa version of the Galaxy S4 is a lot more exciting, but it probably won’t be available in the US — and, more importantly, we just don’t know how its eight cores perform in real-life use: They will almost certainly be lightning fast, but will it be at the expense of injudicious power consumption? (See: Atom vs. Exynos vs. Snapdragon vs. Tegra 3: Which mobile CPU is the most power efficient?)

As the table clearly shows, the Galaxy S4′s hardware is superior to the iPhone 5 in almost every way. The Galaxy S4′s cameras are better on paper, but as we know, more megapixels certainly don’t equate to better image quality. The RAM difference is big, though unlikely to have real-world repercussions; the Galaxy S4′s MicroSD slot is a definite edge over the iPhone 5, however.

Another area where the iPhone 5 might beat the Galaxy S4 is the GPU: In benchmarks, the Snapdragon 600′s Adreno 320 and the iPhone 5′s SGX543MP3 trade blows. In real-life use, the iPhone 5 might feel a bit snappier because its GPU is pushing fewer pixels — and really, we’re still not sure if it makes sense to squeeze a 1920x1080p display into a smartphone. Higher-resolution displays need stronger backlighting and require more processing power, pushing down battery life. If your eye can’t tell the difference between 1080p and 720p at 12 inches, why bother?

It’s also worth noting that the Galaxy S4′s battery is almost twice the size of the iPhone’s — but battery life is unlikely to be twice as long, due to the S4′s huge screen. Apple is famous for its ability to squeeze as much life as possible out of smaller batteries by specifically optimizing the software for the hardware — but even so, I think the S4′s 2,600 mAh battery will win out.

Winner: Galaxy S4

Chassis and dimensions


The one exception to the Galaxy S4′s hardware supremacy, of course, is if you want a smaller phone: The iPhone 5 is both smaller and lighter than the S4 by some margin. The other notable difference is that the Galaxy S4 is plastic, while the iPhone 5 is aluminium (and scuffable!)

Ultimately, though, it comes down to personal taste. While the Galaxy S4 is heavier, at 130 grams it isn’t heavy. If you want a big-screen device, go for the Galaxy; if you want something that’s easier to hold, go for the iPhone.

Winner: It’s a draw


Software


While the hardware specs certainly dictate a few real-world differences between the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 (most notably the iPhone’s lack of NFC and Micro SD slot), the key differentiator is the software. The Galaxy S4, with Android 4.2 and the TouchWiz skin, is completely and utterly different from iOS 6 on the iPhone. Deciding which experience is best, however, is tricky.

Apple’s iOS is something of a paradox, with its proponents claiming that its simplicity is what sets it above the competition, and its foes claiming the exact opposite. If you’ve never used a smartphone before, or if you’ve only ever used an iPhone, you will probably find iOS to be fun and easy to use. At the expense of simplicity, though, you just can’t do a whole lot with an iPhone — at least in comparison to the Galaxy S4. Not only does the iPhone 5 lack the features provided by the S4′s superior hardware (NFC, Micro SD), but iOS is so immutable that you can’t alter basic things like the home screen, web browser, or on-screen keyboard. Basically, iOS/iPhone is one-size-fits-all, and if it doesn’t fit you’re going to wish you’d got the S4 with its elastic waist. (See: Apple iOS 6 vs. Android: Google has some work to do.)

With the Galaxy S4, Samsung also introduced a bunch of crazy new features that iOS/iPhone can only dream of, and probably won’t be replicated even by the time the iPhone 5S or 6 rolls around. For more on how the Galaxy S4′s software is superior to the iPhone 5, see this story: Samsung Galaxy S4: The hardware race is over – software wins again.

Winner: Galaxy S4


Customer support

One important area where Apple still rules supreme is support, both before and after sales. There is simply no Samsung equivalent of the Apple Stores and their in-house Geniuses. As long as you’re happy with web-based and telephone support, though, Samsung is more than capable of walking you through any simple issues you might have. Due to the inherent complexity of Android and TouchWiz, though, you may find yourself wishing for a walk-in Samsung Store.

In terms of warranties, both the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 should come with a one-year manufacturer warranty, but if you’re on-contract it’s generally easier to deal directly with your carrier.

Winner: iPhone 5


First- and third-party ecosystem support

The last differentiator to take a look at is each device’s ecosystem, with regards to both hardware and software. When it comes to software, both the Galaxy S4 (Android) and iPhone 5 (iOS) have access to all of the key apps and games. There are a few platform exclusives, but they’re rare; if you’re buying a smartphone for a specific app, just make sure the phone you choose has access to that app. The Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 both have full cloud connectivity and cloud backup/sync, and both have full access to mapping and turn-by-turn navigation software.

When it comes to first- and third-party hardware accessories, the iPhone has the historical edge — it’s not uncommon for a car to only have an iPhone/iPod connector, and no USB — but support for Android and the Galaxy S4 is growing. You can already get a wireless audio dock that turns your Galaxy into a sound system, a wireless charging plate — and when the S4 launches, there will also be a gamepad accessory, an S Band pedometer/health monitor, a variety of flip covers, and more. Meanwhile, as we’ve already covered in some depth, the iPhone seems to be stagnating. By now we would’ve expected Apple to launch an iTV, or another revolutionary product that perpetuates the iPhone/iPad momentum — but, alas, there’s nothing.

Winner: iPhone 5, but the Galaxy S4 is gaining


Conclusion


So, should you buy the Galaxy S4 or iPhone 5? If we tally up our own scores, the devices have two wins each: the Galaxy S4 wins on hardware and software, while the iPhone 5 wins on customer support and the overall device ecosystem, with the chassis and dimensions perhaps acting as a tie breaker. In other words, you might say that the Galaxy S4 wins on paper, but the overall experience of using an iPhone 5 might be better.

Another potential tiebreaker which we haven’t covered here is connectivity: While both the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 support 4G LTE and 3G HSPA+, their connectivity in other countries will vary. If you intend to travel a lot, you might want to grab an international (Exynos Octa) Galaxy S4, for example. If choosing between the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 comes down to network support, be sure to spend a lot of time talking to carriers and researching the web.

Personally, I would go for the Galaxy S4 — but, if you’re coming from the iPhone, be sure to try it out first. It will be interesting to see if the iPhone 5S, due later this year, can regain the hardware and software crown again — somehow, with Apple’s lack of momentum, I doubt it.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Navigating the Depths: Understanding, Treating, and Preventing Pulmonary Embolism

Pulmonary embolism (PE) is a critical medical condition that demands a comprehensive exploration of its intricacies. In this blog post, we will delve into the causes, diagnostic procedures, treatment options, and preventative strategies to shed light on this often life-threatening occurrence. Unveiling the Causes of Pulmonary Embolism :  1. Deep Vein Thrombosis (DVT): PE often originates from deep vein thrombosis, where blood clots in the deep veins, typically in the legs, can break loose and travel to the lungs.  2. Surgical Procedures and Trauma: Surgery and traumatic injuries can elevate the risk of clot formation, especially during periods of immobilization in the recovery phase. 3. Lifestyle Factors: Obesity, smoking, and sedentary habits contribute to a pro-thrombotic state, increasing the likelihood of DVT and subsequent PE. 4. Genetic and Hormonal Factors: Inherited conditions affecting blood clotting, hormonal contraceptives, and pregnancy can predispose individuals to pulmona
Post a Comment
Read more

Understanding Trans Fats and Their Impact on Heart Health: Unveiling the Science and the Indian Scenario

Trans fats have become a topic of concern in recent years due to their detrimental effects on heart health. These fats, predominantly found in processed foods, pose a significant risk to cardiovascular well-being. In this blog post, we will explore the science behind trans fats, their impact on the heart, shed light on the concerning scenario in India, and discuss common sources of trans fats in our daily diets. Additionally, we will provide practical tips on how to avoid trans fats and make informed choices for a healthier heart. Part 1: The Science Behind Trans Fats and Heart Health What are Trans Fats? Trans fats are artificially created fats formed through a process called hydrogenation. During hydrogenation, liquid vegetable oils are treated with hydrogen gas, leading to the formation of partially hydrogenated oils. These oils contain trans fatty acids, which alter the structure of the fat molecules. The Science Behind Trans Fats and Heart Health : 1. Cholesterol Imbalance : Trans
Post a Comment
Read more

Unlocking Vizag's Potential: Becoming a Dominant Player in India's IT Industry

V izag, with its strategic location and untapped potential, has the opportunity to emerge as a dominant force in India's thriving IT industry. In this blog post, we will explore the key factors that contribute to Vizag's rise and discuss the crucial role that government initiatives can play in attracting IT companies to the region. By leveraging infrastructure, education, and business-friendly policies, Vizag aims to outshine competitors and establish itself as a thriving IT hub. 1. Strategic Government Initiatives : A Catalyst for Growth To transform Vizag into an IT powerhouse, the government needs to implement a range of initiatives, including: - Creating a Conducive Business Environment: The government should offer attractive incentives, tax benefits, and subsidies to entice IT companies to set up operations in Vizag. This business-friendly approach eliminates unnecessary red tape and facilitates a seamless entry into the market. - Developing Cutting-edge Infrastructure
Post a Comment
Read more

Intel 2Q profit jump reflects healthy PC demand

SAN FRANCISCO - Worried that the ailing U.S. economy has spilled abroad and hurt global PC sales, investors had subdued expectations for Intel Corp. in the second quarter. Intel is the world's largest computer chip maker, and its fortunes rise and fall with swings in PC demand. The Santa Clara-based company responded Tuesday with a 25 percent jump in profit and record sales in the quarter, fueled by strong sales of processors for laptop computers. The results easily beat analysts' expectations and reassured Wall Street that Intel is weathering the dreary domestic economy thanks to its broad international reach, a robust product lineup, and a manufacturing advantage over smaller rival Advanced Micro Devices Inc. that lowers Intel's cost of making chips. Intel Chief Executive Officer Paul Otellini said demand for Intel's chips remains strong "in all segments and all parts of the globe." Three-quarters of Intel's business is outside the U.S. Intel shares rose
Post a Comment
Read more

India's Vulnerability to Inflation and Currency Depreciation: Understanding the Major Drawbacks

India, like many countries, faces various challenges that can make it vulnerable to inflation and currency depreciation. Inflation erodes the purchasing power of the currency, while currency depreciation can lead to higher import prices, affecting the economy. In this blog post, we will explore some major drawbacks that leave India vulnerable to these economic issues. 1. High Dependence on Imports India imports a large quantity of crude oil, gold, and other commodities, making it susceptible to fluctuations in global prices. Any sudden increase in the price of these commodities could lead to higher fuel prices, which can then drive up transportation costs and ultimately push prices higher across the economy. In addition, the cost of gold imports can affect the current account deficit and the value of the Rupee. Example: In 2018, global oil prices increased significantly, leading to higher fuel prices in India. This impacted inflation and the value of the Rupee as India is heavily depen
Post a Comment
Read more

The US National Debt: A Serious Problem with Far-Reaching Consequences

The US National Debt A Serious Problem with Far-Reaching Consequences The US national debt is a major problem that could have serious consequences for the US and other countries. The national debt is the total amount of money that the US government owes to its creditors. It is now over $30 trillion, and it is growing at an unsustainable rate. There are a number of reasons for the national debt, including: The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan The Great Recession Tax cuts for the wealthy Increased spending on Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid The national debt is a burden on the economy. It is a drain on resources that could be used for other purposes, and it makes it more difficult for the government to respond to economic challenges. The national debt could also have negative consequences for other countries. If the US government defaults on its debt, it could damage the global economy and lead to a financial crisis. Potential Consequences of the US National Debt He
Post a Comment
Read more