Skip to main content

Which phone is best: Samsung Galaxy S4 vs. iPhone 5



How do you choose between the iPhone 5 and Galaxy S4? On the one hand, the iPhone 5 is an entirely known entity that just works. You might not be getting the most exciting or feature-rich smartphone, but at least you know exactly what you’re getting. Samsung’s Galaxy S4, on the other hand, is world’s apart from the iPhone 5: It’s huge, and massively powerful, and it has a ton of features that might be awesome or gimmicky, depending on your point of view.

The best bet, if you need help choosing between the iPhone 5 and Galaxy S4, is for us to start at the beginning: the hardware. We’ll then work our way up through the software, first- and third-party support, and other features that might break the tie.

Hardware and battery life


For the hardware analysis, we’ll be looking at the US version of the Galaxy S4, which has a quad-core Snapdragon 600 SoC with integrated LTE support. The Exynos Octa version of the Galaxy S4 is a lot more exciting, but it probably won’t be available in the US — and, more importantly, we just don’t know how its eight cores perform in real-life use: They will almost certainly be lightning fast, but will it be at the expense of injudicious power consumption? (See: Atom vs. Exynos vs. Snapdragon vs. Tegra 3: Which mobile CPU is the most power efficient?)

As the table clearly shows, the Galaxy S4′s hardware is superior to the iPhone 5 in almost every way. The Galaxy S4′s cameras are better on paper, but as we know, more megapixels certainly don’t equate to better image quality. The RAM difference is big, though unlikely to have real-world repercussions; the Galaxy S4′s MicroSD slot is a definite edge over the iPhone 5, however.

Another area where the iPhone 5 might beat the Galaxy S4 is the GPU: In benchmarks, the Snapdragon 600′s Adreno 320 and the iPhone 5′s SGX543MP3 trade blows. In real-life use, the iPhone 5 might feel a bit snappier because its GPU is pushing fewer pixels — and really, we’re still not sure if it makes sense to squeeze a 1920x1080p display into a smartphone. Higher-resolution displays need stronger backlighting and require more processing power, pushing down battery life. If your eye can’t tell the difference between 1080p and 720p at 12 inches, why bother?

It’s also worth noting that the Galaxy S4′s battery is almost twice the size of the iPhone’s — but battery life is unlikely to be twice as long, due to the S4′s huge screen. Apple is famous for its ability to squeeze as much life as possible out of smaller batteries by specifically optimizing the software for the hardware — but even so, I think the S4′s 2,600 mAh battery will win out.

Winner: Galaxy S4

Chassis and dimensions


The one exception to the Galaxy S4′s hardware supremacy, of course, is if you want a smaller phone: The iPhone 5 is both smaller and lighter than the S4 by some margin. The other notable difference is that the Galaxy S4 is plastic, while the iPhone 5 is aluminium (and scuffable!)

Ultimately, though, it comes down to personal taste. While the Galaxy S4 is heavier, at 130 grams it isn’t heavy. If you want a big-screen device, go for the Galaxy; if you want something that’s easier to hold, go for the iPhone.

Winner: It’s a draw


Software


While the hardware specs certainly dictate a few real-world differences between the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 (most notably the iPhone’s lack of NFC and Micro SD slot), the key differentiator is the software. The Galaxy S4, with Android 4.2 and the TouchWiz skin, is completely and utterly different from iOS 6 on the iPhone. Deciding which experience is best, however, is tricky.

Apple’s iOS is something of a paradox, with its proponents claiming that its simplicity is what sets it above the competition, and its foes claiming the exact opposite. If you’ve never used a smartphone before, or if you’ve only ever used an iPhone, you will probably find iOS to be fun and easy to use. At the expense of simplicity, though, you just can’t do a whole lot with an iPhone — at least in comparison to the Galaxy S4. Not only does the iPhone 5 lack the features provided by the S4′s superior hardware (NFC, Micro SD), but iOS is so immutable that you can’t alter basic things like the home screen, web browser, or on-screen keyboard. Basically, iOS/iPhone is one-size-fits-all, and if it doesn’t fit you’re going to wish you’d got the S4 with its elastic waist. (See: Apple iOS 6 vs. Android: Google has some work to do.)

With the Galaxy S4, Samsung also introduced a bunch of crazy new features that iOS/iPhone can only dream of, and probably won’t be replicated even by the time the iPhone 5S or 6 rolls around. For more on how the Galaxy S4′s software is superior to the iPhone 5, see this story: Samsung Galaxy S4: The hardware race is over – software wins again.

Winner: Galaxy S4


Customer support

One important area where Apple still rules supreme is support, both before and after sales. There is simply no Samsung equivalent of the Apple Stores and their in-house Geniuses. As long as you’re happy with web-based and telephone support, though, Samsung is more than capable of walking you through any simple issues you might have. Due to the inherent complexity of Android and TouchWiz, though, you may find yourself wishing for a walk-in Samsung Store.

In terms of warranties, both the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 should come with a one-year manufacturer warranty, but if you’re on-contract it’s generally easier to deal directly with your carrier.

Winner: iPhone 5


First- and third-party ecosystem support

The last differentiator to take a look at is each device’s ecosystem, with regards to both hardware and software. When it comes to software, both the Galaxy S4 (Android) and iPhone 5 (iOS) have access to all of the key apps and games. There are a few platform exclusives, but they’re rare; if you’re buying a smartphone for a specific app, just make sure the phone you choose has access to that app. The Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 both have full cloud connectivity and cloud backup/sync, and both have full access to mapping and turn-by-turn navigation software.

When it comes to first- and third-party hardware accessories, the iPhone has the historical edge — it’s not uncommon for a car to only have an iPhone/iPod connector, and no USB — but support for Android and the Galaxy S4 is growing. You can already get a wireless audio dock that turns your Galaxy into a sound system, a wireless charging plate — and when the S4 launches, there will also be a gamepad accessory, an S Band pedometer/health monitor, a variety of flip covers, and more. Meanwhile, as we’ve already covered in some depth, the iPhone seems to be stagnating. By now we would’ve expected Apple to launch an iTV, or another revolutionary product that perpetuates the iPhone/iPad momentum — but, alas, there’s nothing.

Winner: iPhone 5, but the Galaxy S4 is gaining


Conclusion


So, should you buy the Galaxy S4 or iPhone 5? If we tally up our own scores, the devices have two wins each: the Galaxy S4 wins on hardware and software, while the iPhone 5 wins on customer support and the overall device ecosystem, with the chassis and dimensions perhaps acting as a tie breaker. In other words, you might say that the Galaxy S4 wins on paper, but the overall experience of using an iPhone 5 might be better.

Another potential tiebreaker which we haven’t covered here is connectivity: While both the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 support 4G LTE and 3G HSPA+, their connectivity in other countries will vary. If you intend to travel a lot, you might want to grab an international (Exynos Octa) Galaxy S4, for example. If choosing between the Galaxy S4 and iPhone 5 comes down to network support, be sure to spend a lot of time talking to carriers and researching the web.

Personally, I would go for the Galaxy S4 — but, if you’re coming from the iPhone, be sure to try it out first. It will be interesting to see if the iPhone 5S, due later this year, can regain the hardware and software crown again — somehow, with Apple’s lack of momentum, I doubt it.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Return of Trump: What India's Economy and Job Market Can Expect

Donald Trump has made a comeback, winning the U.S. presidential election once again. With his return to the White House, there are many questions about how his policies will impact India's economy, especially regarding U.S.-based jobs and trade relations. Trump's previous tenure was characterized by his "America First" agenda, which significantly influenced global trade, immigration, and outsourcing dynamics. In this blog, we explore the potential advantages and challenges India may face under Trump's renewed leadership. 1. H-1B Visa and Immigration Policies: A Renewed Challenge During his previous term, Trump tightened immigration rules, especially concerning the H-1B visa program. This program is crucial for India's IT sector, which relies on sending skilled professionals to the U.S. What We Can Expect : Stricter Visa Norms : Trump's administration is likely to continue enforcing strict H-1B visa policies. This could mean increased scrutiny, higher rejec...

The State of Quantum Computing in 2024: Where Are We Now?

  Quantum computing is one of the most exciting and rapidly advancing fields in technology today. As we step into 2024, it’s clear that quantum computing is no longer a distant dream but a rapidly evolving reality. However, the journey from theoretical models to practical applications is still ongoing. So, where do we stand with quantum computing today? Let’s explore the current landscape, the breakthroughs, and what lies ahead. 1. The Hardware Frontier: Scaling Up Qubits One of the most critical aspects of quantum computing is the hardware itself. Unlike classical computers, which use bits to represent data as 0s and 1s, quantum computers use  qubits  that can exist in multiple states simultaneously, thanks to the principles of  superposition  and  entanglement . Recent Hardware Advancements IBM  remains a leader in quantum hardware, having recently introduced its new  “Condor” quantum processor , which boasts over  1,121 qubits . This is a ...

Rethinking Exercise: Lessons from an Evolutionary Biologist

Harvard professor and evolutionary biologist Daniel Lieberman challenges many of the commonly held beliefs about exercise, sleep, and the human body. Lieberman, who is also the author of the book   Exercised , draws on his extensive research to argue that our modern lifestyle has led to a "mismatch" between our evolved biology and the environment we live in today. This disconnect, he suggests, is a significant factor behind many of the health problems we face. Here are some of the most eye-opening takeaways from Lieberman's interview: 1. The Myth of 8 Hours of Sleep We’ve all heard that 8 hours of sleep is the gold standard for health. However, Lieberman argues that this one-size-fits-all approach to sleep is misleading. He references studies on hunter-gatherer societies, who live without the influence of artificial lighting and other modern sleep disruptors. Surprisingly, these populations typically sleep between 6-7 hours a night. Lieberman suggests that, for most peopl...

The Deadly Naegleria fowleri: The Brain-Eating Amoeba Found in India

 When we think of life-threatening infections, we usually consider bacteria or viruses. However, lurking in warm freshwater bodies is a far deadlier yet lesser-known microorganism—Naegleria fowleri, often referred to as the "brain-eating amoeba." This microscopic organism thrives in warm, stagnant water and, if it enters the body through the nose, can cause a severe and almost always fatal brain infection called Primary Amebic Meningoencephalitis (PAM). In this blog, we will explore: What is Naegleria fowleri? How does it affect the brain? Confirmed cases in India and affected states Precautions to prevent infection What is Naegleria fowleri? Naegleria fowleri is a single-celled amoeba found in warm freshwater such as: Ponds, lakes, and rivers Hot springs Poorly maintained swimming pools Untreated water storage tanks It thrives at temperatures above 25°C and can survive up to 46°C, making it a potential risk in tropical and subtropical regions, including Indi...

Bhagat Singh: A Journey from Revolutionary to Philosopher in Prison

 Bhagat Singh’s life was an extraordinary evolution—from a fiery revolutionary to a contemplative philosopher whose ideas continue to inspire generations. His imprisonment, far from breaking his spirit, became a crucible where his thoughts deepened, his ideals sharpened, and his legacy solidified. By tracing his journey from youthful defiance to mature intellectualism, we see how his life became a testament to the enduring power of ideas. The Early Revolutionary: Planting the Seeds of Defiance Bhagat Singh’s revolutionary spirit was sparked by the brutalities of British rule, most notably the Jallianwala Bagh massacre of 1919. As a young boy, he was deeply moved by the blood-soaked soil of Amritsar, which solidified his commitment to India's independence. Early on, he drew inspiration from leaders like Lala Lajpat Rai and global revolutionary movements. In 1929, Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt orchestrated the Central Legislative Assembly bombing, a symbolic act designed to aw...

The Economic Rebirth of India: How 1991 Reforms Transformed the Nation

A Tribute to Dr. Manmohan Singh Today, as we mourn the loss of Dr. Manmohan Singh, we pause to honor one of India’s greatest statesmen. A visionary economist and humble leader, Dr. Singh’s contributions shaped modern India, steering the nation through one of its darkest economic crises and paving the way for its rise as a global powerhouse. His legacy as the architect of India’s liberalization reforms is unparalleled, and his profound impact on the lives of millions will be remembered for generations. Dr. Singh exemplified leadership marked by intellect, integrity, and quiet determination. His policies transformed the Indian economy, dismantling stagnation and laying the groundwork for sustained growth. Even beyond his tenure as Finance Minister and later as Prime Minister, his wisdom and statesmanship continued to inspire the nation. This blog post delves deeper into Dr. Singh’s extraordinary contributions, particularly during the pivotal 1991 economic reforms, and reflects on the par...